Truly Memorable StayPosted: Fri, Jul 18 2008Location:
4Rooms:
3.8Service:
2.9Value:
5Belated review- Stayed here with my parents for 4 nights back in April. I booked through AMEX Platinum's Fine Hotels program. Maybe that was the reason, or maybe the hotel service is always this excellent, but we were treated like VIPs throughout our stay. Upon arrival, we were upgraded to a 5th-floor deluxe suite, with a welcome platter of fresh fruit and a bottle of wine awaiting our entry. The room was beautifully appointed with traditional decor. Large comfy bed, luxurious curtains, even a tapestry! Separate bedroom and sitting area with a TV in each, and a balcony with a view of the Duomo and the Palazzo Vecchio. The room was not soundproofed, but I have yet to come across a hotel room in Italy that is. Also, the bathroom exhibited a slightly funky odor, but was otherwise functional and spacious. So overall, the suite was gorgeous and comfortable with only a couple of minor inconveniences.
As for the hotel itself, the common areas are a stylish blend of past and present. There's a lovely courtyard with a swimming pool, and adjacent to that is the Conservatory restaurant. The breakfast buffet is average, but definitely have dinner here if you can! Best Italian meal I've ever had, hands down. Even a place like Babbo's in NY doesn't compare. Of course, it probably helped that we went on an off-season weeknight and were essentially treated to a private dinner. Still, wow.
Location: As others have written, the hotel is a 10-15 minute walk from most city attractions. But it's located in a relatively quiet neighborhood. Plus it's very close to the SMN bus/train terminal, which is convenient for day excursions to Siena and other Tuscan towns, or for arrivals/departures via Eurostar.
Finally, it's worth noting that Travel & Leisure magazine just ranked the Grand Hotel Villa Medici 35th in all of Europe. That's better than any other Fiorentine hotel. Considering that the place doesn't seem to be as well-known as some of its neighbors (yet), this means that we're looking at a hidden gem.